Salvatores By Papà Reno Italian Restaurant Menu

When you walk into Salvatores By Papà Reno Italian Restaurant, you’re immediately transported to a cozy, welcoming corner of Italy. Located at 313 E 2nd St in Muscatine, IA, this charming spot offers an authentic Italian dining experience that’s perfect for any occasion. The menu is a delightful journey through Italy's most beloved dishes, each one crafted with fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes.

From hearty pastas like rich, creamy fettuccine Alfredo to wood-fired pizzas with the perfect balance of crispy crust and gooey cheese, every bite brings a taste of Italy. If you're in the mood for something a little different, the seafood selections are just as mouthwatering, with dishes that highlight the fresh flavors of the coast. And let’s not forget about the mouthwatering desserts - a perfect way to end your meal on a sweet note.

Whether you’re a long-time local or visiting for the first time, Salvatores By Papà Reno feels like home. It's the kind of place where food is meant to be savored, and every dish has a story to tell.

Regular Thin Crust Pizza

Cheese
$
1 Item
$
2 Items
$
3 Items
$
4 Items
$
Specialty
$

Sicilian Pan and Sicilian Stuffed Pizza

Cheese
$
1 Item
$
2 Items
$
3 Items
$
4 Items
$
Specialty
$

Signature Pizzas

Special
Our Best Seller! Red sauce, fresh Italian sausage, prosciutto (ham), pepperoni, mozzarella, mushroom, bell pepper, onions
$
All Meat
Red sauce, fresh Italian sausage, Angus ground beef, mozzarella, pepperoni, and Canadian Bacon
$
Taco
Red sauce, refried beans, Angus ground been, taco seasoning, mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, and taco chips
$
Claudio's Chicken Ranch
Homemade ranch dressing, grilled chicken strips, real bacon, and mozzarella cheese
$
Veggie
Red sauce, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, black olives, covered in mozzarella cheese
$
Roma's
Italian sausage, fresh garlic, Roma tomatoes, topped with olive oil, a sprinkle of oregano, and mozzarella
$
Steak Pizza
White sauce, sliced steak, fresh mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, and mozzarella cheese. Add $2
$
Mimma's Seafood
Alfredo sauce, wild caught shrimp, crab meat, and mozzarella cheese
$
Cappricciosa
Red sauce, fresh Italian sausage, prosciutto, fresh mushrooms, fresh onions, artichokes, and mozzarella
$
Romano Ranch
Ranch dressing, fresh garlic, fresh tomatoes, spinach, fresh mushrooms, and topped with mozzarella
$
Pizza 4-Formaggi
Red sauce, Romano, Parmigiano Reggiano, cheddar, and mozzarella cheeses
$
Pizza Margherita
A House Favorite! Red sauce, fresh Roma tomatoes, basil, extra virgin olive oil, and fresh mozzarella
$
Pizza Macaroni
Cream sauce, pasta noodles, cheddar cheese, and mozzarella cheese
$
Diavola Pizza
Red sauce, sausage, jalapeños, pepperoni, hot sauce blend, and mozzarella cheese
$

Insalate Salad

Piccola
Our special side salad of mixed fresh salad greens, freshly chopped tomatoes, Parmesan, croutons, and your choice of homemade salad dressing
US$3.95
Insalata
Mixed fresh salad greens, freshly chopped tomatoes, green and black olives, Parmesan, croutons, and your choice of homemade salad dressing
US$5.95
Tuscany Salad
Fresh salad greens, fresh tomatoes, bell peppers, mushrooms, Italian ham, onions, pepperoni, Parmesan, mozzarella, croutons and your choice of homemade salad dressing
US$8.95
Famiglia Insalate
Fresh salad greens, bell peppers, tomatoes, black olives, onions, & cheese. Feeds up to 4
US$10.95

Antipasti Appetizers

Mozzarella Bread
Freshly grated mozzarella cheese and creamy garlic butter toasted on a panini bread
US$5.95
Cheese Sticks
A House Favorite! Mozzarella cheese melted on top of Salvatore's homemade pizza dough, topped with garlic butter and parmesan
US$7.95
Bruschette Al Pomodoro
Toasted Italian bread slices, topped with fresh tomatoes, oregano, fresh garlic, and sprinkled with Parmigiano Reggiano cheese
US$7.95
Larry's Toasted Ravioli
Breaded ravioli stuffed with a blend of sausage and cheese. Served with marinara. (Please allow extra time)
US$8.95
Tomato Asiago (Seasonal)
Fresh sliced Roma tomatoes, topped with a creamy Asiago and three cheese blend
US$8.95
Italian Meatballs
Italian meatballs, simmered in red wine, bell peppers, onions, and San Marzano tomatoes
US$9.95
Pescatore Bruschette (Seasonal)
Lightly toasted Italian bread slices, topped with homemade Alfredo sauce, shrimp, crab, and Parmigiano Reggiano cheese
US$9.95

Drinks

Pepsi
$
Diet Pepsi
$
Cherry Pepsi
$
Moutain Dew
$
Root Beer
$
Iced Tea
$
Sierra Mist
$

Bottled Domestic

Bud Light
$
Coors Light
$
Miller Lite
$
Budweiser
$

Bottled Imports

Peroni
US$3.95

On Tap

AmberBock
$
Fat Tire
$
Michelob Ultra
$

Vino Wines

Vino Wines
Inquire about our selection of fine imported wines
$

Lavazza Caffe Coffee

Espresso
US$2.50
Cappuccino/Latte
US$2.95
Caffe' Americano
US$1.95

Bottled Water

San Pellegrino
$
Aqua Panna
$

Paninis Hot Sandwiches

Ham and Cheese Panino
Sliced pit ham, mozzarella cheese and mayo layered on fresh Italian bread and toasted Panini style
US$6.75
Italian Poor Boy
Freshly sliced pit ham, mayo, pepperoni, lettuce, tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese, toasted Panini style
US$7.95
Italian Sausage
Italian Sausage layered on a panini bread topped with homemade red meat sauce and mozzarella
US$7.95
Italian Meatball
Italian meatballs lining toasted Italian bread, covered with our homemade red meat sauce and mozzarella
US$7.95
Italian Beef
Freshly sliced roast beef, topped with red sauce and cheese. We suggest adding fresh bell peppers and onions
US$7.95
Steak Panino
Sliced Angus steak simmered in a cream sauce. We suggest adding bell peppers, mushrooms, and onions
US$8.95

Pasta Ripiena Filled Pasta

Manicotti
Large tender rolls of pasta stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese covered with our homemade red meat sauce and oven-baked. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Merlot
US$9.95
Portabella Ravioli
Large tender pasta pillows filled with Portabello mushrooms and covered with our classic white cream sauce of melted butter, pure cream, and freshly grated Parmesan cheese. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Pinot Grigio
US$12.95
Ravioli Ripiene con Carne
Tender ravioli pasta stuffed with seasoned meat and covered with our authentic homemade Italian red meat sauce. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Lambrusco
US$10.95
Spinach & Chicken Ravioli
Large tender pasta pillows filled with spinach, chicken and covered with our classic white cream sauce of melted butter, pure cream, and freshly grated Parmesan cheese. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Pinot Grigio
US$13.95

Cucina Classica Classic Recipes

Spaghetti
A plate of steaming spaghetti pasta cooked al dente topped with homemade Italian meat sauce, simmered all day for that special Italian flavor. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Lambrusco
US$8.95
Anthony's Fettuccine Alfredo
Freshly prepared egg fettuccine cooked al dente and tossed with our classic mascarpone alfredo sauce, sprinkled with parmesan. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Pinot Grigio
US$10.95
Spaghetti Alla Reno
A plate of spaghetti tossed in olive oil, fresh garlic, chilled roma tomatoes, sprinkled with Parmigiano Reggiano cheese. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Chardonnay
US$15.95
Lasagna Classico
Pasta sheets layered with freshly prepared homemade meat sauce and four Italian cheeses; mozzarella, ricotta, Parmesan & Romano. Cooked to perfection. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Pinot Lambrusco
US$11.95
Sabrina's Ziti
Our Best Seller! Penne pasta cooked al denta and sauteed in a blend of meat sauce ragu and Mascarpone sauce. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Chianti
US$10.95

Pollo, Pesce e Carne Chicken, Seafood, & Steak

Chicken Parmigiana
A plate of spaghetti topped with check breasts breaded in a harb seasoning; covered with our homemade tomato sauce and oven baked to perfection. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Pinot Grigio
US$12.95
Lobster Ravioli (Seasonal)
Large tender pasta pillows filled with fresh lobster and covered with our classic white cream sauce. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Chardonnay
US$17.95
Chicken Marsala
Tender chicken filets, lightly breaded, simmered with fresh portabella mushrooms, and marsala wine, served over steamed fettuccine noodles. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Pinot Grigio
US$18.95
Seafood Alla Mimma
Sauteed wild caught shrimp and crab meat tossed with fettuccine noodles and tossed with our famous alfredo sauce. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Pinot Grigio
US$14.95
Seafood Estella
Linguini pasta, sauteed wild caught shrimp and crab tossed in a spicy pink sauce. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Chardonnay
US$15.95
Reno's Famous Ribeye
Approx. 18 oz. Black Angus ribeye, marinated in olive oil and garlic; then grilled. Served with spaghetti and salad. Subject to Availability. Available in Rare, Medium or Well Done. Any variation from this is not guaranteed. Wine Pairing Suggestion: Chianti
US$23.95

Bambini Kids

Spaghetti
US$5.95
Fettuccine Alfredo
US$7.95

Dolce Dessert

Cheesecake Delight
New York style cheesecake slices, topped with either Ghirardelli chocolate, or caramel sauce. Inquire about fruit toppings
US$3.95
Cannoli
Available in Season. Delicate pastry tube filled with ricotta cannoli filling, made fresh in our kitchen. Decorated with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce
US$4.25
Tiramisù
Available in Season. Two layers of Savoiardi cookies, mascarpone cheese, whipped cream, and espresso coffee, made fresh in our kitchen. Drizzled with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce
US$4.95
Italian Wedding Cake
A light Italian-style cream cake featuring bright lemon mascarpone filling that hits the perfect mark between sweet and tart. It's finished with a delicate dusting of powdered sugar
US$4.95

Red Wines

Stemmari Cabernet Sauvignon, Sicily, Italy IGT
Emergent notes of black currant and ripe cherries that are well-integrated with inklings of spice that are derived from the refinement in wood
$
Merlot, Sicily, Italy IGT
Ample and intense, with aromas of red ripe fruit like cherries, raspberries, and blackberries with nuances of red fruit. It is surrounded with spicy notes that are derived from the aging in wood
$
Zonin Chianti, Toscana, Italy DOCG
Dry and fresh, with good body and agreeable tannins. It has a fruity and persistent taste with a lightly spicy background
$
Stemmari Nero D'Avola, Sicily, Italy IGT
Deep ruby-red with notes of currant stick out, wild strawberries, and pomegranate. Soft and velvety. Overall a great wine
$
Santa Cristina Sangiovese, Toscana, Italy IGT
Ruby color with an intense bouquet of cherry and raspberry fruits, along with hints of violet and tobacco. Smooth and well-structured with delicious tannins
$

White Wines

Tavolo Matto Pinot Grigio, Veneto, Italy IGT
Light-bodied, with an alluring tropical-fruit bouquet; ripe melon and pear flavors
$
Stemmari Chardonnay, Sicily, Italy IGT
Harmonious and balanced, with pleasant viscosity that balances the delicate acidity with hints of pineapple, tropical fruits and vanilla
$
Coastal Ridge White Zin, Napa, California
Sumptuous, refreshing flavor of apricot, strawberry, and melon. The long, slightly sweet finish invites the next sip
$

Sparkling Wines

Umberto Fiore Moscato D'Asti, Asti, Italy DOCG
Extremely aromatic with a sweet and light taste. Sparkling or vivacious. Enjoy with desserts or as an aperitif. Our most served
$
Zonin Lambrusco, Emilia, Italy
Light, Fruity and floral with nuances of roses and underbrush and small red fruit. A semi sweet and very pleasant wine with a distinctive raspberry taste
$

Reserve Wines

Olianas Cannonau, Sardinia, Italy DOC
Young, full-bodied and characterful, the wine is a delightful introduction to an ancient variety. A Blue Zones wine selection
US$29.95
Allegrini Valpolicella, Veneto, Italy DOC
Vibrant ruby red in color with fresh cherry aromas. This is the perfect accompaniment to Italian Antipasti and pasta dishes
US$34.95
Masi Campofiorin, Verona, Italy IGT
The "Supervenetian" mad from Veronese grapes utilizing the famed Masi Double Fermentation technique. Bold and rich flavors of bitter cherries and berry fruits stand out with balanced acidity and velvety tannins
US$39.95
Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa, California
Dark ruby color and an enticing nose of cases, black truffles and violets. On the palate, the wine has an elegant attack and bursts with flavors of fresh forest fruit, potpourri and Asian spices
US$95.95
Banfi Brunello, Montalcino, Italy DOCG
Intense ruby red in color with garnet reflections. Aromas of violets and vanilla, with hints of licorice. Velvety palate, with tart-cherry flavors and traces of spice
US$105.95
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available.